==============================================================================
PAPER 13 COMPARATIVE GROUNDING  -  sourced comparison
==============================================================================

[A] CATEGORICAL TABLE (every cell sourced; see AUDIT.md)
System             Funding               Builds        Brake Maturity
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
UBI                general taxation      flow          No    pilots
Social Security    payroll tax, pay-as-y flow          No    proven
SWF / Alaska       resource rents (oil/m stock+flow    No    proven
Georgism (LVT)     land rents            flow          No    partial
Citizens Standard  growth-tied money iss stock+flow    Yes   theoretical

[B] COMPARABLE AXIS 1 - annual per-person benefit (real USD/yr)
  UBI                 12000.0                universal flow
  Social Security     22800.0                contributory, retirement only (NOT universal working-age)
  SWF / Alaska        1600.0                 universal resident dividend
  Citizens Standard   B:$516.0/C:$2388.0     universal dividend (theoretical)
  Georgism (LVT)      n/a                    DIFFERS IN KIND: funding source, pays no per-person benefit

[C] COMPARABLE AXIS 2 - owned wealth stock per person (real USD)
  SWF / Alaska        132969                     collective fund / per-resident share (proven)
  Citizens Standard   A:$233,000.0/B:$413,000.0  owned, locked, bequeathable floor (theoretical)
  Social Security     0                          DIFFERS IN KIND: no property right (Flemming v. Nestor)
  UBI                 0                          DIFFERS IN KIND: income flow, builds no owned stock
  Georgism (LVT)      None                       DIFFERS IN KIND: funding source only

[D] COMPARABLE AXIS 3 - funding sustainability / capture
  Social Security     PAYGO; OASI depletes 2033, ~77% payable (~23% cut); $22.6T unfunded
  SWF / Alaska        corpus constitutionally protected; statutory dividend formula abandoned since 2016
  UBI                 gross cost ~$3.1T/yr at $1,000/mo x 258M adults; Ontario pilot cancelled on cost
  Georgism (LVT)      $1.1-3.36T/yr potential, ~zero deadweight; never adopted as national single-tax
  Citizens Standard   issuance base disappears in contraction; procyclical dividend halts in downturns

[E] CLAIM CHECKS
  claim1_distinctive_cell: holds=True
      only system meeting all three: ['Citizens Standard']
  claim2_where_dominated: holds=True
  claim4_binding_condition: holds=True
Traceback (most recent call last):
  File "/home/claude/work/bundle/replication/Citizens-Standard-replication/comparative_replication/src/compare.py", line 227, in <module>
    with open("../results/comparison_results.json", "w") as fh:
         ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
FileNotFoundError: [Errno 2] No such file or directory: '../results/comparison_results.json'
